Skip to content
UnitFormula

A loan comparison runs the same amount under different rates and terms so the trade-off is visible. $250,000 at 6.5% over 30 years is $1,580.17 a month and about $568,861 in total; at 6% over 15 years it is $2,109.64 a month but only about $379,736 in total. Each payment uses the standard amortization formula with a monthly rate of the annual rate ÷ 12. A longer term lowers the payment and raises total interest.

Loan Calculator — compare rates & terms side by side

%
yr
%
yr

Comparing a $250,000 loan: 6.5% over 30 yrs vs 6% over 15 yrs.

Scenario A payment$1,580.17
Scenario B payment
$2,109.64
Scenario A total cost
$568,861.22
Scenario B total cost
$379,735.57

Quick examples

How it's calculated

  1. Scenario A monthly paymentMA=P rA(1+rA)nA(1+rA)nA−1M_A = P\,\frac{r_A(1+r_A)^{n_A}}{(1+r_A)^{n_A}-1}
    P
    = 250,000
    r
    = 0.005417
    n
    = 360
    1,580.17
  2. Scenario B monthly paymentMB=P rB(1+rB)nB(1+rB)nB−1M_B = P\,\frac{r_B(1+r_B)^{n_B}}{(1+r_B)^{n_B}-1}
    P
    = 250,000
    r
    = 0.005
    n
    = 180
    2,109.64

Compare scenarios

Scenarios side by side; where one is highlighted, it has the lowest value in the compared column.
RateTerm (yr)Monthly paymentTotal interestTotal cost
6.5%30$1,580.17$318,861$568,861
6%15$2,109.64$129,736$379,736
Scenario A payment$1,580.17

How it works

This calculator takes one loan amount and runs it through two or three scenarios — each a rate and a term — so you can compare them directly. For each scenario the monthly payment comes from the amortization formula, M = P·r(1+r)ⁿ ⁄ ((1+r)ⁿ − 1) — P the loan amount, r the monthly rate (the annual rate divided by 12), and n the number of payments — and the total cost is that payment multiplied by the number of payments, the amount you repay over the whole loan. Comparing scenarios makes the two levers visible: a longer term shrinks the monthly payment but stretches interest over more years, so it usually costs more in total; a lower rate reduces both the payment and the total. The scenario with the lowest total cost is highlighted.

Worked example

A $250,000 loan at 6% over 30 years has a monthly payment of about $1,498.88 (LibreTexts). Kept to term, that is 360 payments totalling roughly $539,600 (LibreTexts) — more than double the amount borrowed, because interest accrues for thirty years. The same $250,000 over 15 years costs more each month but far less overall, since the balance is gone in half the time. Set the two against each other and the monthly-vs-lifetime trade-off is explicit rather than buried.

More worked examples

Each row is computed by this calculator: scenario A vs scenario B on the same amount (fixed rate, monthly payments).

Loan: A vs BA monthlyA total costB monthlyB total cost
$250,000: 6.5% / 30 yr vs 6% / 15 yr$1,580.17$568,861.22$2,109.64$379,735.57
$30,000: 8% / 5 yr vs 8% / 3 yr$608.29$36,497.51$940.09$33,843.27
$10,000: 12% / 3 yr vs 9% / 3 yr$332.14$11,957.15$318.00$11,447.90
$400,000: 7% / 30 yr vs 6.5% / 30 yr$2,661.21$958,035.59$2,528.27$910,177.95

Edge cases

  • Third scenario: leave its rate and term at 0 to compare just two.
  • Same rate, different terms: the shorter term always has the higher monthly payment and the lower total cost (row 2 above).
  • Rates run 0.1–30% and terms 1–40 years. Interest-only, balloon and variable-rate loans are not modelled.
  • Extra payments are not modelled here. Use the amortization calculator to see what paying extra each month saves.

Method note

Each scenario uses the standard fixed-rate amortization payment with monthly compounding (annual rate ÷ 12). Total cost is the amount borrowed plus all interest over the full term. Fees, points and insurance are not included, which is why a lender's APR can differ from the rate you enter.

Frequently asked questions

What does this loan calculator compare?

It compares the monthly payment and total cost of one loan amount under two or three different rate-and-term scenarios. It is built for questions like "15-year vs 30-year?" or "is shopping for a rate half a point lower worth it?" — where you want to see the options next to each other.

How is each scenario's total cost calculated?

Each scenario's monthly payment comes from the standard amortization formula (the loan amount, the monthly rate, and the number of payments); its total cost is that payment multiplied by the number of payments — the full amount you repay. The total is what this page compares: a lower monthly payment often carries a higher total, and putting both numbers side by side for each scenario is the point.

Is a shorter term or a lower rate better?

It depends on what you are optimising. A shorter term raises the monthly payment but cuts total interest sharply; a lower rate helps both. The comparison highlights the lowest total cost, but the right choice also depends on what monthly payment you can comfortably afford — so weigh both columns.

Why does a 15-year scenario cost less overall than a 30-year?

Seen side by side at the same rate, the 15-year option carries a higher monthly payment but a much lower total cost: interest is charged on the outstanding balance, and a 15-year loan clears that balance in half the time, so far fewer months of interest accrue. Comparing whole loans this way surfaces the size of that monthly-versus-lifetime trade-off for your own amount and rates.

How is this different from the amortization calculator?

This page compares whole loans against each other — which one to take. The amortization calculator takes a single loan and shows how its balance unwinds month by month, splitting each payment into principal and interest. Use this to choose a loan, and amortization to understand the one you chose.

What should I put in the third scenario?

Scenario C is optional — leave its rate and term at zero to compare just two loans. Reveal it under advanced options when you want a third option in the mix, such as a second lender's quote or an in-between term.

When would a real loan's payments differ from this schedule?

The payments and totals are exact for fixed-rate loans held to term. It excludes fees and points rolled into some loans, variable rates, and early payoff — so treat the totals as a like-for-like comparison of the loans as quoted, and confirm the details against each lender's offer.

How we know this is right

Last reviewed
Jul 20, 2026
Precision
Rounded to 2 decimal places.
Read our methodology

Abdilahi Qayre, MSc, Founder and Editor

LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/abdilahi-qayre-220ba528

Sources