A loan comparison runs the same amount under different rates and terms so the trade-off is visible. $250,000 at 6.5% over 30 years is $1,580.17 a month and about $568,861 in total; at 6% over 15 years it is $2,109.64 a month but only about $379,736 in total. Each payment uses the standard amortization formula with a monthly rate of the annual rate ÷ 12. A longer term lowers the payment and raises total interest.
Loan Calculator — compare rates & terms side by side
Comparing a $250,000 loan: 6.5% over 30 yrs vs 6% over 15 yrs.
- Scenario B payment
- $2,109.64
- Scenario A total cost
- $568,861.22
- Scenario B total cost
- $379,735.57
Quick examples
How it's calculated
- Scenario A monthly payment
- P
- = 250,000
- r
- = 0.005417
- n
- = 360
- 1,580.17
- Scenario B monthly payment
- P
- = 250,000
- r
- = 0.005
- n
- = 180
- 2,109.64
Compare scenarios
| Rate | Term (yr) | Monthly payment | Total interest | Total cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.5% | 30 | $1,580.17 | $318,861 | $568,861 |
| 6% | 15 | $2,109.64 | $129,736 | $379,736 |
How it works
This calculator takes one loan amount and runs it through two or three scenarios — each a rate and a term — so you can compare them directly. For each scenario the monthly payment comes from the amortization formula, M = P·r(1+r)ⁿ ⁄ ((1+r)ⁿ − 1) — P the loan amount, r the monthly rate (the annual rate divided by 12), and n the number of payments — and the total cost is that payment multiplied by the number of payments, the amount you repay over the whole loan. Comparing scenarios makes the two levers visible: a longer term shrinks the monthly payment but stretches interest over more years, so it usually costs more in total; a lower rate reduces both the payment and the total. The scenario with the lowest total cost is highlighted.
Worked example
A $250,000 loan at 6% over 30 years has a monthly payment of about $1,498.88 (LibreTexts). Kept to term, that is 360 payments totalling roughly $539,600 (LibreTexts) — more than double the amount borrowed, because interest accrues for thirty years. The same $250,000 over 15 years costs more each month but far less overall, since the balance is gone in half the time. Set the two against each other and the monthly-vs-lifetime trade-off is explicit rather than buried.
More worked examples
Each row is computed by this calculator: scenario A vs scenario B on the same amount (fixed rate, monthly payments).
| Loan: A vs B | A monthly | A total cost | B monthly | B total cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000: 6.5% / 30 yr vs 6% / 15 yr | $1,580.17 | $568,861.22 | $2,109.64 | $379,735.57 |
| $30,000: 8% / 5 yr vs 8% / 3 yr | $608.29 | $36,497.51 | $940.09 | $33,843.27 |
| $10,000: 12% / 3 yr vs 9% / 3 yr | $332.14 | $11,957.15 | $318.00 | $11,447.90 |
| $400,000: 7% / 30 yr vs 6.5% / 30 yr | $2,661.21 | $958,035.59 | $2,528.27 | $910,177.95 |
Edge cases
- Third scenario: leave its rate and term at 0 to compare just two.
- Same rate, different terms: the shorter term always has the higher monthly payment and the lower total cost (row 2 above).
- Rates run 0.1–30% and terms 1–40 years. Interest-only, balloon and variable-rate loans are not modelled.
- Extra payments are not modelled here. Use the amortization calculator to see what paying extra each month saves.
Method note
Each scenario uses the standard fixed-rate amortization payment with monthly compounding (annual rate ÷ 12). Total cost is the amount borrowed plus all interest over the full term. Fees, points and insurance are not included, which is why a lender's APR can differ from the rate you enter.
Frequently asked questions
What does this loan calculator compare?
- It compares the monthly payment and total cost of one loan amount under two or three different rate-and-term scenarios. It is built for questions like "15-year vs 30-year?" or "is shopping for a rate half a point lower worth it?" — where you want to see the options next to each other.
How is each scenario's total cost calculated?
- Each scenario's monthly payment comes from the standard amortization formula (the loan amount, the monthly rate, and the number of payments); its total cost is that payment multiplied by the number of payments — the full amount you repay. The total is what this page compares: a lower monthly payment often carries a higher total, and putting both numbers side by side for each scenario is the point.
Is a shorter term or a lower rate better?
- It depends on what you are optimising. A shorter term raises the monthly payment but cuts total interest sharply; a lower rate helps both. The comparison highlights the lowest total cost, but the right choice also depends on what monthly payment you can comfortably afford — so weigh both columns.
Why does a 15-year scenario cost less overall than a 30-year?
- Seen side by side at the same rate, the 15-year option carries a higher monthly payment but a much lower total cost: interest is charged on the outstanding balance, and a 15-year loan clears that balance in half the time, so far fewer months of interest accrue. Comparing whole loans this way surfaces the size of that monthly-versus-lifetime trade-off for your own amount and rates.
How is this different from the amortization calculator?
- This page compares whole loans against each other — which one to take. The amortization calculator takes a single loan and shows how its balance unwinds month by month, splitting each payment into principal and interest. Use this to choose a loan, and amortization to understand the one you chose.
What should I put in the third scenario?
- Scenario C is optional — leave its rate and term at zero to compare just two loans. Reveal it under advanced options when you want a third option in the mix, such as a second lender's quote or an in-between term.
When would a real loan's payments differ from this schedule?
- The payments and totals are exact for fixed-rate loans held to term. It excludes fees and points rolled into some loans, variable rates, and early payoff — so treat the totals as a like-for-like comparison of the loans as quoted, and confirm the details against each lender's offer.
How we know this is right
- Last reviewed
- Jul 20, 2026
- Precision
- Rounded to 2 decimal places.
Abdilahi Qayre, MSc, Founder and Editor
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau How do mortgage lenders calculate monthly payments? · Reviewed Jul 20, 2026
- LibreTexts (Las Positas College) Amortized Loans (Math for Liberal Arts, §8.05) · Reviewed Jul 18, 2026